Biggest Sale of the Year

Dr. Colbert’s Divine Health: 25% off sitewide with code BLACKFRIDAY202625% Off | Code BLACKFRIDAY2026Shop Divine Health
100% FreeDr. Colbert’s 21 Day Keto Zone Challenge·Meal plans, recipes and daily guidance. Start any time.Join Free
DrColbert.com

Faith-Based Wellness

Dr. Don Colbert, MD

New York Times Bestselling Author

Your trusted source for health articles, recipes, and spiritual wellness from the doctor behind Divine Health.

Black coffee with a small pitcher of cream and cinnamon on a sunny porch, a simple swap for non-dairy creamer calories
Healthy Living Articles Weight Loss & Keto

Non-Dairy Creamer Calories Outpace Sugar, New Tufts Study Finds

Coffee CaloriesNon-Dairy CreamerHealthy CoffeeLabel ReadingHidden Saturated FatTufts ResearchFood-First Living

Picture the coffee table in the church fellowship hall after Sunday service. Beside the big urn sits a basket of little single-serve cups of creamer: French vanilla, hazelnut, caramel. Most of us grab one without a second thought. After all, it says “non-dairy,” so it must be the lighter choice, right?

A new analysis from Tufts University suggests we take a closer look. Researchers found that non-dairy creamer calories have become the largest source of added calories in American coffee, edging out sugar and syrups. Americans are not drinking more coffee than before, yet the calories in their cups rose by nearly 40 percent between 2003 and 2018. You can read the summary on ScienceDaily.

Let me say this right away: this is not a story about giving up coffee. In my practice, I often tell patients that coffee can be a wonderful part of a healthy life. This is a story about what goes into the cup, and how small habits repeated every morning add up over the years.

60average daily calories from coffee in 2018, up from 43 in 2003
18.5daily calories from non-dairy creamer in 2018, more than sugar (16)
30,000U.S. adults in the national survey data

🔬 What the Study Found About Non-Dairy Creamer Calories

The research team, Yongyi Pan, Bingjie Zhou and Fang Fang Zhang, published their findings in 2026 in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. The paper is newly released online ahead of its print issue. They used the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), a large government survey designed to represent the eating habits of the whole country.

The team looked at eight survey cycles from 2003 to 2018. About 30,000 adults aged 20 and older took part (one write-up from StudyFinds puts the exact number at 30,459). Each person completed two “24-hour dietary recalls,” which means a trained interviewer asked them to describe everything they ate and drank the day before.

Here is what the researchers found:

  • Coffee volume stayed steady. Americans drank roughly 13 ounces of coffee a day, and that hardly changed over 15 years.
  • Coffee calories climbed. Daily calories from coffee rose from 43 to 60, an increase of nearly 40 percent.
  • Creamer took the lead. By 2018, non-dairy creamer added 18.5 calories a day, compared with 16 from sugar or syrup and 11 from dairy milk. Back in 2003, creamer added just 7.71 calories a day.
  • Creamer use more than doubled. Non-dairy creamer intake rose from 3.37 to 8 grams a day. Non-dairy milk (such as almond or oat milk) rose from 0.27 to 2.45 grams a day.
  • Other add-ins held steady. Dairy milk, sugar and sugar substitutes showed no significant change.
💡

Did You Know?

By weight, dairy milk was still the most common coffee add-in in 2018 at 21.4 grams a day, compared with 8.1 grams of non-dairy creamer. Yet the creamer, at well under half the amount, added more calories than the milk did.

The study turned up one more detail I found telling. People who slept fewer hours or worked longer hours tended to drink more coffee. Coffee intake was about the same whether a person’s overall diet was healthier or less healthy.

What This Study Can and Cannot Tell Us

I always want you to know how strong the evidence is. This was an observational study, which means researchers tracked what people reported eating and drinking. It measured no health outcomes at all, so it cannot show that creamer causes weight gain or any illness.

There are other limits too. Memory-based food reports are prone to error and vary from day to day. The data end in 2018, so today’s habits may look different. And the calorie figures are averages across the whole population, including people who drink no coffee. That means someone who enjoys a creamy cup every morning is likely getting more than 18.5 calories a day from creamer. One study is never the final word, but it is a helpful mirror.

⚖️ Is Non-Dairy Creamer Bad for You? Why “Non-Dairy” Doesn’t Mean Lighter

Many of my patients switched to non-dairy creamer years ago because they assumed it was the lighter option. The word “non-dairy” simply means the product contains no milk. It says nothing about calories, fat or sugar.

Lead author Yongyi Pan suggested a reason creamer calories add up: many non-dairy creamers can be high in saturated fat, which is calorie-dense. That is the authors’ proposed explanation, and the study did not test it directly. According to StudyFinds’ review of the paper, many powdered creamers are roughly 20 percent saturated fat by weight, and some are made with hydrogenated oils, which can add trans fat or a large amount of saturated fat depending on how they are processed.

Hydrogenated oils are vegetable oils that have been chemically altered to stay solid and shelf-stable. That is very different from the fat that comes naturally in whole foods. If you have wondered how naturally occurring fats in real dairy compare, I walked through a research review on dairy trans fats and heart health that you may find helpful.

Creamer Is Not the Same as Non-Dairy Milk

Here is an important distinction. Non-dairy creamer and non-dairy milk are two different things. According to StudyFinds’ summary, the non-dairy milks in this study added far fewer calories than creamers did. A plain, unsweetened almond or oat milk is usually a simpler product than a flavored creamer built on oils and sweeteners.

The Power of “Stealth” Sources

A few extra calories may not sound like much. But researchers at Ohio State University studied 36,378 U.S. adults and found saturated fat made up at least 12 percent of daily calories, with added sugar at 14 to 16 percent. They listed “cream substitutes” among the sources of saturated fat and noted that small, “stealthy” sources add up over the course of a day.

That is the real lesson here. It is rarely one big meal that shapes our health. It is the quiet, automatic choices we make every single morning without thinking.

The Good News About Coffee Itself

Coffee on its own has a lot going for it. Senior author Fang Fang Zhang noted that coffee is often accompanied by sugar and cream, which add calories from added sugar and saturated fat. In other words, the cup is often fine; it is the extras we need to watch. I have also written about how coffee may affect gut health, even decaf.

☕

Recent Research

An earlier Tufts study of 46,000 adults found that black coffee, or coffee with low added sugar and saturated fat, was linked with a 14% lower risk of death from any cause compared with no coffee. “Low” meant under about 2.5 grams of sugar (about half a teaspoon) and about 1 gram of saturated fat per 8-ounce cup. The same link was not seen for heavily sweetened, creamy coffee. This was observational, so it shows an association, not proof. Read the study summary.

🌿 Healthy Coffee Creamer Alternatives and How to Make Coffee Healthier

When patients ask me how to make coffee healthier, I don’t hand them a list of rules. I encourage them to return to real food: simple ingredients God designed, used in modest amounts. Here are the swaps I suggest most often.

☕

Learn to Love It Black

Black coffee was the style linked with lower mortality in the earlier Tufts research. If it tastes harsh, try a lighter roast or cut your add-ins by a little each week. Your taste buds adjust faster than you think.

🥛

A Measured Splash of Real Cream or Milk

If you love creamy coffee, a small splash of real cream or whole milk gives you a short, recognizable ingredient list. Real cream is still rich, so measure it with a spoon instead of pouring freely.

🌰

Unsweetened Nut or Oat Milk

If you avoid dairy, choose a plain, unsweetened non-dairy milk rather than a flavored creamer. Look for a short ingredient list without added sugars or hydrogenated oils.

🍂

Flavor With Spices, Not Syrups

A pinch of cinnamon, nutmeg or cardamom, a drop of pure vanilla extract, or a little unsweetened cocoa gives your cup warmth and aroma without the bottled sweeteners.

🔍

Read the Label Like a Detective

Check the serving size, saturated fat and added sugar. Scan for “hydrogenated” or “partially hydrogenated” oils. If the first ingredients are sugar and oil, it is a flavored fat product, not milk.

🥄

Make Your Own Simple Creamer

Warm a cup of whole milk or unsweetened nut milk with a cinnamon stick and a split vanilla bean, then keep it in a jar in the fridge. You choose every ingredient.

Look at What’s Driving the Extra Cups

Remember the finding about sleep and work hours. When we are short on rest, we tend to reach for more coffee, and often a sweeter, creamier one for comfort. Protecting your sleep may quietly reduce how many cups you need in the first place. If you are running on fumes, my article on why carb cravings hit so hard explains how tiredness and cravings feed each other.

A word for those of you following a keto lifestyle: I know many of you enjoy coffee with real fats. That can fit a well-planned eating pattern, but calories still count, and real food beats a shelf-stable powder every time. If you would like guided support building clean, simple habits, my free 21-Day Keto Zone Challenge is a great place to start.

If you are managing your weight, cholesterol, blood sugar or a heart condition, talk with your own doctor about your daily coffee add-ins. Small details matter more when your body is already working hard.

✦ Dr. Colbert’s Faith Perspective

Faithful in the Little Things

Scripture teaches that our bodies are temples of the Holy Spirit and that we are called to glorify God in them (1 Corinthians 6:19 to 20). Stewardship is not only about the big decisions. It is lived out in a hundred small, ordinary moments, including the one at the coffee pot each morning.

Proverbs reminds us, “The simple believes every word, but the prudent considers well his steps” (Proverbs 14:15). A word like “non-dairy” on the front of a package is not the whole story. Turning it over and reading the label is a small act of wisdom. And as Jesus taught, faithfulness in small things grows into faithfulness in much.

“He who is faithful in what is least is faithful also in much; and he who is unjust in what is least is unjust also in much.” (Luke 16:10, NKJV)

“Your morning cup is not the enemy. It is simply a daily invitation to choose real food, read wisely, and honor the body God gave you, one sip at a time.”

Dr. Don Colbert, MD

✅ Your 7-Step Coffee Action Plan

  1. Take inventory this week. Notice how many cups you drink and exactly what you add to each one. Awareness is the first step.
  2. Read your creamer label. Check the serving size, saturated fat, added sugar and the first few ingredients. Look for hydrogenated oils.
  3. Measure instead of pouring. Use a spoon for a week. Many people are surprised how much more they add than the listed serving.
  4. Make one swap. Try a splash of real cream, whole milk, or an unsweetened non-dairy milk in place of flavored creamer.
  5. Add flavor from the spice rack. Cinnamon, nutmeg, pure vanilla or unsweetened cocoa can replace syrups and sweet creamers.
  6. Taper toward black. Cut your add-ins a little each week until your coffee is lightly dressed or black.
  7. Protect your sleep. Aim for a consistent bedtime so you are not leaning on extra cups to get through the day, and thank God for each restful night.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Is non-dairy creamer bad for you?

This study did not measure health outcomes, so it cannot say creamer is harmful. What it does show is that non-dairy creamer is now the top source of added calories in American coffee. The researchers say many creamers can be high in saturated fat, so reading the label and keeping portions small is a wise approach.

How many calories does creamer add to coffee?

Across the whole U.S. adult population, non-dairy creamer added about 18.5 calories a day in 2018. That average includes people who drink no coffee, so a daily creamer user likely gets more. Your own number depends on the product and how much you pour, which is why measuring helps.

What is the healthiest thing to put in coffee?

The simplest options are best: nothing at all, a measured splash of real cream or milk, or an unsweetened non-dairy milk with a short ingredient list. Spices like cinnamon and nutmeg add flavor without added sugar. In observational research from Tufts, black or lightly dressed coffee was the style linked with lower mortality.

Are non-dairy milks better than non-dairy creamers?

They are different products. According to StudyFinds’ summary of this study, non-dairy milks added far fewer calories than creamers. Choose a plain, unsweetened version and check that it has no added sugars or hydrogenated oils.

Should I stop drinking coffee?

Not based on this study. Coffee intake itself stayed steady; it was the add-ins that changed. If you have a health condition or take medication, ask your doctor what amount and style of coffee is right for you.

🙏 A Final Word on Your Morning Cup

I love that this research doesn’t ask anyone to give up a simple pleasure. It just invites us to pay attention. Over 15 years, Americans didn’t drink more coffee; they simply poured more into it, often without realizing it.

You are fearfully and wonderfully made (Psalm 139:14), and you deserve to fuel that body with real, simple food. Start with one cup tomorrow morning. Read the label, measure your splash, sprinkle a little cinnamon, and say a quiet prayer of thanks for a new day. Small faithful steps truly add up.

If this was helpful, share it with someone you sit with at the church coffee table, and keep visiting for more research made simple. To your health and God’s blessings,

Dr. Don Colbert, MD

Sources

  1. Coffee calories have jumped nearly 40%. Sugar isn’t the biggest culprit, ScienceDaily / Tufts University, 2026
  2. Pan Y, Zhou B, Zhang FF. Trends in the Consumption of Coffee and Coffee Additions Among U.S. Adults Aged 20+ Years, The National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2003-2018, Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 2026 (online ahead of print)
  3. Americans are adding more calories to their coffee, Futurity / Tufts University, 2026
  4. Non-Dairy Creamers Are Secretly Adding Calories To Your Morning Coffee, U.S. News & World Report (HealthDay), 2026
  5. Americans Are Turning Morning Coffee Into Calorie Bombs, and Sugar Isn’t the Problem, StudyFinds, 2026
  6. Black coffee, longer life: The science behind your morning perk, ScienceDaily / Tufts University (Zhou et al., The Journal of Nutrition), 2025
  7. Identifying ‘stealth’ sources of saturated fat, added sugar in the diet, ScienceDaily / Ohio State University (Taylor et al., Nutrients), 2024
Medical Disclaimer: This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult your physician before beginning any supplement, diet or exercise program, especially if you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication or managing a health condition.

Was this helpful?

What stood out to you most, and have you tried any of this yourself?

Tell us on Facebook