5 Ingredients That Should NEVER Be In Your Health Shake

Even if a label says it’s healthy, calls it a “health shake,” and claims it will make all your dreams come true, you should always double-check the ingredients and nutrition of any so-called health shake.

If any of these ingredients appear in the ingredients list, put the shake down and walk away.

Here are 5 ingredients that should NEVER be in your health shake, and how marketing can make it difficult to determine how healthy a shake really is.

Health Shake Claims and Confusion

Like most food packaging, many health shakes have confusion labels. You’ll find false or exaggerated claims on the front of a package. Unless it’s a strict health claim, it’s not well regulated.

As the consumer, it’s up to you to investigate beyond these claims.

To start, follow my #1 rule for food packaging:

Ignore everything you read on the front side of the packaging. It’s marketing. Some marketing is truthful. Some isn’t. 

Then, go to the ingredients list. Although there is still some ambiguity here, with ingredients like “natural flavors,” etc., it’s still a better gauge than product packaging claims. You’ll get a good idea of what’s in the food or shake.

Decide: Are you okay with everything that’s in it? If so, move on to the nutrition label.

If you want to stay in the Keto Zone, pay special attention to total carbs and fiber to calculate the net carbs. Pay extra special attention to the portion size listed at the top of the label. And, beware of these 5 ingredients:

5 Ingredients That Should NEVER Be in Your Health Shake

Soybean Oil, Peanut Oil, and Other High Omega-6 Oils

Omega-6 oils actually work against omega-3 oils. Omega-6 oils are associated with declines in metabolic health, cardiovascular health, and increased inflammation (123).

In fact, one aim of a great diet is to get your omega-6 to omega-3 ratio as low as possible. The average American diet is at about a 20:1 omega-6 to omega-3 ratio. An optimal ratio is considered 4:1. Anything below 10:1 is a good goal in modern times.

Why is it so hard to get to optimal levels?

High omega-6 oils, like soybean oils, are literally everywhere in the food supply. Take a look in your cupboard, it’s there.

When you look at your health shake, look for:

Good Oils for Health Shakes:

  • MCT oils and organic coconut oil (0.4 gm omega-6)
  • Olive oil (1.3 gm)
  • Avocado oil (1.8 gm)
  • Occasional Use: High-oleic sunflower (0.5 gm), high-oleic safflower oils (2.0 gm)


  • Safflower oil (10.1 gm omega-6)
  • Grapeseed oil (9.5 gm)
  • Vegetable oil (7.9 gm)
  • Wheat Germ oil (7.5 gm)
  • Corn oil (7.3 gm)
  • Walnut oil (7.3 gm)
  • Cottonseed oil (7.0 gm)
  • Soybean oil (7.0 gm)
  • Sunflower oil (5.4 gm)
  • Canola oil (3.0 gm)

Added and Hidden Sugars

Sugary liquids are the epitome of insulin-disturbing, health-wrecking foods. These sugars travel through the digestive tract very quickly, are 100% absorbed, and spike blood sugar.

It is the exact opposite of what you want on a healthy Keto Zone diet.

In fact, many of them will be liquid sugars, such as high fructose corn syrup, rice syrup, or cane sugar syrup. Don’t be fooled. It’s all added sugar.

High sugar intake is linked to poor health, inflammation, cardiovascular disease, and more. It’s associated with brain aging, and may even be linked to degenerative diseases (4).

Walk away from high-sugar “health” shakes.

“Healthy” Sugars

You may also see syrups and sweeteners that seem “healthy.”

Agave may seem healthier than other sugars, but it’s not. In fact, it is a liquid sweetener, high in fructose. Fructose is metabolized in the liver, turns into triglycerides and fat, and breaks down collagen and elastin.

And while real maple and honey have some positive health attributes, they contain too many carbohydrates for a Keto Zone Diet.

Aspartame and Saccharin

Man-made artificial sweeteners have been widely used in “diet foods.” Unfortunately, they can have negative effects on gut bacteria.
Animal and humans studies have shown that aspartame, saccharin, sucralose, and other artificial sweeteners can impair gut bacteria (5).
In fact, there is documentation of (6):
  • Saccharin reducing healthy bacteria growth by 40%
  • Sucralose decreasing bacteria by more than 2-fold
  • Aspartame increasing the number of harmful bacteria by 10%

If you use sugar substitutes, make sure they are natural ones like sugar alcohols: erythritol, xylitol, and others is safe, and do not seem to affect gut bacteria (7).

Any good health shake should allow your gut “rest” and healing, along with good-bacteria proliferation.

Fake Flavorings and Colorings

Food dyes are not benign and have no place in a “health” shake.

Several studies have found that food dyes exacerbate hyperactivity in sensitive children (8). While you may be an adult, this finding confirms that food dyes make their way into our systems and can affect our bodies.

What’s more, Red 3 is a dye that was banned in the 1990s, and then had the ban retracted. Lab studies have shown tumor concerns with Red 3, and may people anecdotal report intolerances for it (910).

Bottom Line

Always check your ingredients list, whether looking at a candy bar or “health” shake. If choosing a Keto Zone Shake, you can skip it. Just kidding! Still, check those ingredients. You’ll find only health-benefiting ones, and you’ll never find any of these 5 ingredients that should NEVER be in your health shake! Go ahead, take a look.


  1. Gail Cheshier says:

    thank you this was very enlightening – information I needed. A great deal of it I was aware of but did learn about a few that I thought were okay – again many thanks.

  2. Donna Patrice Lumpkin says:

    This was and is an eye opener for me. I know I have to leave the CHIPS alone, and start reading my Keto Zone Book that I purchased. I also purchased the Green Food but have not been doing that very well. I realize there is no need of me exercising like I have been if I don’t LEAVE certain foods alone and stick with the plan. I am a serious “Believer” in Christ and know that HE wants us free of diseases, etc. It’s never too late to start over again. Today is the day!!. Thank you, Doctor.

  3. Louis E. Woodland says:

    Thank you. Will past this information on.

  4. D. Marion Gregg says:

    I was previously unaware that one of the reasons to avoid “bad” oils is the omega 6 to omega 3 ratio. The basic diet “rule” I TRY to follow is (3 parts): no sweetener except stevia; only occasional whole grains (no white flour ever); and, no “bad” oils. One of the problems I have is explaining to other people what is “good” or “bad” about certain oils. Now I have one more explanation. I’ve found that by following my “rule” my weight stays about the same and I don’t have food cravings.

  5. Elaine T says:

    Yes, I have been on Keto Zone following Dr Colbert’s books, the Keto Zone & the Keto Zone Cookbook.
    I added some natural fruits & non dairy icecream & there are so many hidden additives that I gained 20 lbs in these past 2 months. Didny know until I checied the scale!
    Even natural sugar in fruits besides berries & food additives have an effect on the diet.
    I am going to make my own icecream so I can count carbs & avoid additives & nix the summet fruit.
    Every single thing we put into our body should be accounted for!

  6. Pat Eagle says:

    Ive been confessing the Word over my life since 2008, it works for our good folks. Lately Ive discovered to be reaping a harvest of GOOD, praise God for Divine Health and Trivita. I just get better and better.

  7. Joyce Ford says:

    Thank you so much, Dr. Colbert. I appreciate your work and dedication. I hope some day to be able to start the Keto, modified for me. Its,all about the finances. I do want a healthy and we’ll temple for the plans and purposes my Holy Father has foe me. Thank you for your prayers for me. Joy

  8. Lesley Swain says:

    God BLESS you Dr. Colbert❣Where would we be without you to navigate for us through these perilious days of so many fake and unhealthy foods?! Just hard to get my mind around the food industry being so greedy. My 90 yr. old mom would never believe that food just isn’t what it used to be in her generation(and she never did😓). I think many in her generation feel like that. Probably why they now have so many health issues? Bless their hearts. You’re a gift to our generation!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *